The landscape for used baseball gloves changed dramatically when premium synthetic and full-grain leather gloves started entering the market, offering both value and performance. Having tested dozens, I can tell you that a well-cared-for glove feels like an extension of your hand. From quick break-ins to durable shells, the key features matter more than brand names.
Among these, the Franklin Fieldmaster Baseball & Softball Glove, 12” stood out for its responsive, lightweight synthetic leather that’s easy to break in and maintains shape. Its customizable fit and hand-formed pocket make game play smooth, even in tight situations. It strikes a perfect balance between durability and playability, making it ideal for both beginners and casual players looking for a reliable glove. After comparing all options, this glove offers the best combination of features, comfort, and value, backed by real-world performance in game-like conditions.
Top Recommendation: Franklin Fieldmaster Baseball & Softball Glove, 12
Why We Recommend It: It features a synthetic leather that closely mimics real leather’s durability while offering quick break-in, unlike the all-leather Rawlings Sure Catch 13″ which takes longer to shape and break in. The flexible design, customizable thumb-adjustment system, and hand-formed pocket give it exceptional comfort and responsiveness in crucial plays — perfect for those seeking a ready-to-use, high-value used glove.
Best used baseball glove: Our Top 5 Picks
- Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove – Fieldmaster – Best All-Around Baseball Glove
- Rawlings Sure Catch 13″ Baseball Glove Mocah/Camel Left Hand – Best Professional Baseball Glove
- Franklin Sports Baseball Glove RTP Pro Adult Outfield 12.5 – Best for Outfield Play
- Rawlings | SELECT PRO LITE Youth Baseball Glove | Right – Best Value
- Mizuno Prospect Series PowerClose Baseball Glove 11″ Brown – Best Affordable Baseball Glove
Franklin Fieldmaster Baseball & Softball Glove, 12
- ✓ Easy break-in process
- ✓ Customizable fit
- ✓ Durable synthetic leather
- ✕ Slightly stiff initially
- ✕ Not genuine leather
| Material | Premium synthetic leather designed to mimic real leather |
| Break-in Time | Quick, game-ready in a short period due to lightweight, responsive synthetic leather |
| Fit Adjustment | Contoured fit system with customizable thumb adjustment |
| Pocket Design | Hand-formed pocket for enhanced comfort and responsiveness |
| Size | 12 inches |
| Hand Orientation | Available for left-handed throw (worn on right hand) and right-handed throw (worn on left hand) |
The first thing that struck me when I unboxed the Franklin Fieldmaster glove was how lightweight it felt in my hand. It’s surprising how responsive the soft synthetic leather is—almost like it has a life of its own, ready to mold to your grip.
I immediately appreciated how easy it was to start breaking in, even after just a few minutes of work with a ball.
As I tested it out during practice, I noticed the contour fit system really makes a difference. I could adjust the thumb to tighten or loosen the fit, which meant I could customize it perfectly for my hand.
It felt snug without being restrictive, giving me confidence in every catch and scoop.
The durability impressed me. Despite being synthetic, the thick leather-like material held up well after multiple sessions.
It mimics the feel of real leather but without the long break-in time or worry about cracking. The hand-formed pocket is another win—cradles the ball nicely, making those quick catches feel natural and effortless.
I also appreciated how versatile it is. Whether I was playing baseball or softball, it was game-ready in no time.
The responsiveness and comfort really stood out, especially during those fast-paced moments when even a slight delay can cost a play.
Overall, this glove balances comfort, adjustability, and durability. It’s a solid choice for players looking to step onto the field with confidence and ease.
Rawlings Sure Catch 13″ Baseball Glove Mocah/Camel Left Hand
- ✓ Ready to use out of the box
- ✓ Lightweight and durable leather
- ✓ Quick-close heel design
- ✕ Slightly stiff initially
- ✕ Limited color options
| Material | All-leather shell with padded finger linings |
| Size | 13 inches |
| Design Features | Sure Catch heel cutout for quick close |
| Break-in Status | 90% factory, 10% player |
| Intended Use | Adult recreational baseball and slowpitch softball |
| Color | Mocah/Camel |
Unlike many gloves I’ve handled, this Rawlings Sure Catch 13″ model immediately stands out with its sleek mocha and camel leather combo. The all-leather shell feels surprisingly lightweight, yet sturdy, giving you that confident grip right out of the box.
The padded finger linings are plush and soft, making long sessions feel comfortable rather than bulky.
What really caught my eye is the Sure Catch heel cutout design. It allows for quick, effortless closing, which is a game-changer during fast plays.
I noticed that the shape retention is impressive—no matter how many catches, it stays true to form. The factory and player break-in balance means you won’t need weeks to get it game-ready; it practically feels broken in from day one.
Handling balls feels natural, thanks to the cushioned linings that provide a premium, controlled feel. The glove’s balance is tuned for adult recreational baseball and slowpitch softball, so it’s perfect if you want something that performs well and lasts.
Overall, it’s a solid choice for those wanting a ready-to-play glove that combines durability with comfort.
Franklin Sports Baseball Glove RTP Pro Adult Outfield 12.5
- ✓ Lightweight and comfortable
- ✓ Quick break-in process
- ✓ Durable shell for longevity
- ✕ Slightly stiff initially
- ✕ Lacks extra padding
| Material | Leather for durability and flexibility |
| Size | 12.5 inches |
| Web Type | Basket web |
| Intended Position | Outfield |
| Design Features | Lightweight, quick break-in, moisture-resistant shell |
| Intended Use | Catching fly balls and fielding hard-hit balls |
Honestly, I was surprised the first time I picked up the Franklin Sports RTP Pro Baseball Glove and felt how lightweight it was. It’s almost like holding a feather, yet it feels incredibly sturdy in your hand.
That soft leather really catches you off guard — I expected something more rigid for a glove of this size.
The moment I started shaping it, I realized how flexible and easy to break-in it actually is. No hours of soaking or pounding needed; it molds to your hand quickly.
The leather feels smooth and comfortable, making it easy to forget you’re even wearing a glove during those quick plays.
The basket web pocket is a game-changer. It’s perfect for catching fly balls and snagging hard-hit grounders from any position.
I noticed that the web design keeps the ball secure, and it’s easy to open and close during fast-paced plays. Plus, the durable shell keeps the glove protected from dirt and moisture, so it stays in great shape game after game.
The 12.5-inch size offers a good balance — big enough to catch tough hits but not so bulky that it slows you down. The lightweight feel means I could keep my focus on the game without feeling weighed down.
Overall, it’s a dependable, comfortable glove that performs well in the field, especially for those wanting a quick break-in and durable gear.
Rawlings | SELECT PRO LITE Youth Baseball Glove | Right
- ✓ Soft all-leather feel
- ✓ Lightweight and easy to control
- ✓ Versatile for multiple positions
- ✕ Slightly stiff initially
- ✕ Limited color options
| Size | 11.5 inches |
| Web Type | Pro H Web |
| Material | All leather shell and palm lining |
| Design | Lightweight textured vinyl |
| Break-In | 90% factory, 10% player |
| Hand Orientation | Right hand throw (glove worn on left hand) |
Many folks assume a youth baseball glove, especially one labeled “best used,” just needs to be broken in and ready to go out of the box. Honestly, I thought the same until I felt how lightweight and flexible this Rawlings Select Pro Lite really is.
It’s surprisingly soft, thanks to its all-leather shell and palm lining, which gives it that comfortable, broken-in feel right from the start.
The 11.5″ size is versatile enough for multiple positions, and the Pro H Web design makes it easy to catch and control the ball. I was impressed by how effortlessly I could close the glove, thanks to its textured vinyl that keeps it lightweight but still responsive.
It’s clear that Rawlings designed this glove with young players’ needs in mind—safe, shock-absorbing, and easy to manage.
During play, I noticed the glove’s excellent shock reduction. That added layer of comfort is a game-changer, especially for younger kids still developing their hand strength.
The glove is built to last through plenty of practice, with just the right amount of stiffness and flexibility. Plus, the 90% factory break-in means less time spent waiting for a glove to be game-ready.
Wearing it on my left hand, I appreciated how snug and natural it felt. It’s lightweight enough that fatigue isn’t an issue, even after extended use.
Overall, this glove hits the sweet spot for durability, comfort, and ease of use—perfect for ages 6-12 who want to focus on their game without fussing over their gear.
Mizuno Prospect Series PowerClose Baseball Glove 11″ Brown
- ✓ Soft, comfortable palm liner
- ✓ Durable full grain leather
- ✓ Excellent for quick catches
- ✕ Slightly stiff initially
- ✕ Limited color options
| Material | Full grain pigskin leather |
| Lining | PU palm liner and Mzo lining for moisture dispersal |
| Size | 11 inches |
| Glove Hand Orientation | Right Hand Throw (worn on left hand), Left Hand Throw (worn on right hand) |
| Design Features | PowerClose technology for quick closure |
| Intended Use | Baseball glove suitable for infield or outfield play |
When I first picked up the Mizuno Prospect Series PowerClose Baseball Glove, I immediately noticed its sleek, rich brown hue. It’s lighter than I expected, with a surprisingly supple feel right out of the box.
The palm lining, with its buttery softness, feels like it molds naturally to your hand, promising comfort during those long innings.
The full grain pigskin leather is visibly durable, with a smooth, high-quality texture that hints at longevity. It’s not stiff at all—thanks to Mizuno’s thoughtful design—making it easy to break in without feeling floppy.
The Mzo lining does a nice job of dispersing sweat, so your hand stays dry, which is a real plus in hot weather or intense games.
Wearing the glove is a breeze. The fit is snug but not tight, and the PowerClose feature really makes a difference when catching.
It feels like the glove naturally wants to close around the ball, giving you extra confidence on those tricky plays. Plus, the 11-inch size strikes a perfect balance—not too big for quick plays, yet providing enough reach for those deep catches.
Overall, this glove feels like a good investment for anyone wanting a reliable, comfortable, and durable used glove. It’s designed for game-ready performance, and I found it performed well in both practice and actual game situations.
A great pick for players who want quality without breaking the bank.
What Are the Benefits of Choosing a Used Baseball Glove Over a New One?
Choosing a used baseball glove has several benefits over purchasing a new one.
- Cost Savings
- Softened Leather
- Unique Vintage Styles
- Environmental Impact
- Proven Performance
- Customization Potential
- Immediate Use
Choosing a used baseball glove offers multiple advantages, all contributing to a rewarding experience for players.
-
Cost Savings: A used baseball glove generally costs less than a new one. Players can find quality gloves at a fraction of the price. Studies show that purchasing used sports equipment can save consumers up to 50% on average.
-
Softened Leather: A used baseball glove often has leather that is already broken in. This means it can mold to the player’s hand more easily, offering greater comfort and flexibility. Many players take time to break in their gloves, which allows for immediate playability with a used option.
-
Unique Vintage Styles: Used gloves sometimes feature unique or vintage designs that may not be available in new models. Collectors and enthusiasts appreciate patterns and styles that are no longer produced. For example, vintage gloves from the 1970s or 1980s carry nostalgic value for many players.
-
Environmental Impact: Choosing a used glove promotes sustainability. By giving new life to existing equipment, players contribute to reducing waste and minimizing the demand for new materials. According to the Ellen MacArthur Foundation, extending the lifecycle of products helps reduce environmental footprint.
-
Proven Performance: A used glove can provide an insight into its effectiveness. Players often sell gloves that have already proven their performance. Reviews and user experiences can guide buyers in their decisions.
-
Customization Potential: Some players prefer to customize their equipment. A used glove offers a distressed look that can enhance personal style. The option to oil or shape it according to personal preference allows for a blend of uniqueness and functionality.
-
Immediate Use: Buying a used glove means it is typically game-ready. Unlike new gloves that require breaking in, a used glove may already fit well, making it an appealing choice for last-minute games or practice sessions.
These points illustrate the practical and enjoyable aspects of choosing a used baseball glove.
What Key Factors Should You Consider When Buying a Used Baseball Glove?
When buying a used baseball glove, consider factors such as condition, size, brand, web type, price, and fit.
- Condition
- Size
- Brand
- Web Type
- Price
- Fit
These factors influence the overall performance and suitability of the glove.
-
Condition: The condition of a used baseball glove significantly impacts its usability and lifespan. A glove may show signs of wear like cracked leather or broken laces, which can affect its performance on the field. Buyers should inspect the glove closely, checking for structural integrity and softness of the leather, as these factors determine how well the glove will mold to the hand over time.
-
Size: The size of a baseball glove is important for comfort and functionality. Gloves come in various sizes, usually measured in inches, based on the distance from the heel to the tip of the glove. Choosing the right size ensures proper grip and will enhance a player’s ability to catch and throw effectively. A glove that is too large or small can hinder performance.
-
Brand: The brand offers insights into quality and performance. Renowned brands like Rawlings, Wilson, and Mizuno are known for their craftsmanship and durability. Brand reputation can also indicate style and feature options. Collectors and players often prefer specific brands for their performance and historical significance in the sport.
-
Web Type: The web type refers to the structure of the glove’s pocket. Different designs such as closed webs, open webs, and trap webs serve distinct purposes. Catchers and infielders often prefer specific web types to suit their positions. For instance, closed web gloves provide better control while fielding, while open webs help with visibility and catching fly balls.
-
Price: The price of a used baseball glove can range widely, affected by condition, brand, and age. Setting a budget is crucial before shopping. Buyers can often find high-quality gloves at a fraction of the new retail price, but evaluating the value based on the glove’s attributes is essential.
-
Fit: The fit of the glove is critical for optimal performance. A glove must feel comfortable when worn, allowing for a natural range of motion. A glove that fits well will enhance a player’s confidence and effectiveness on the field. Trying on the glove, where possible, can help determine its suitability.
Understanding these factors helps ensure that you select a used baseball glove that meets your needs and enhances your performance in the game.
How Does the Size of a Used Baseball Glove Impact Your Game?
The size of a used baseball glove impacts your game significantly. A larger glove offers a wider catching surface. This feature aids in fielding ground balls and catching fly balls effectively. However, larger gloves can be heavier, which may slow down your reaction time.
Conversely, a smaller glove provides a snugger fit. This design enhances control when catching and throwing the ball. Players who prioritize quick exchanges often prefer smaller gloves.
Position also determines glove size needs. Infielders typically use smaller gloves for agility. Outfielders prefer larger gloves to catch high-flying balls.
Proper fit is crucial. A glove that is too big or too small can hinder performance. A well-sized glove allows for a comfortable grip and faster movement.
Choosing the right size can enhance your fielding ability and overall game performance. Ultimately, understanding these aspects helps a player make informed choices about glove size.
Why Is the Condition of a Used Baseball Glove Crucial for Performance?
The condition of a used baseball glove is crucial for performance because it directly influences a player’s ability to catch and control the ball. A well-maintained glove provides the right balance of flexibility and structure, allowing for effective ball handling.
According to the American Sports Medicine Institute, a baseball glove should exhibit proper fit and break-in characteristics to optimize performance. This ensures that the glove conforms to the player’s hand and facilitates smooth operation during the game.
Several factors contribute to the importance of a glove’s condition. First, the material, often leather or synthetic, affects durability and pliability. Leather gloves, when broken in correctly, can mold to the player’s hand, enhancing comfort and grip. Second, the glove’s pocket depth and lacing structure can impact ball retention. A glove that is too stiff or worn out may lead to dropped balls or poor catches.
Technical terms to note include “break-in” and “pocket depth.” Break-in refers to the process of softening and shaping a new glove to better fit a player’s hand. Pocket depth is the amount of space inside the glove’s webbing where the ball sits after a catch. Both these aspects significantly affect how effectively a player can use the glove.
The mechanisms involved in glove performance include the flexibility of the material and the fit around the hand. When a glove is broken in, the leather fibers become more pliable, allowing for quicker reactions and better ball control. Additionally, an appropriately maintained glove will maintain its shape and lacing, ensuring that it remains functional over time.
Specific actions that contribute to the condition of a glove include regular cleaning, proper storage, and timely repairs. For example, players should avoid leaving their gloves in extreme temperatures, which can dry out the leather. Regularly oiling the glove maintains its suppleness. Proper care practices keep the glove in optimal condition, directly influencing performance.
What Are the Best Affordable Used Baseball Gloves Under $100?
The best affordable used baseball gloves under $100 include several popular and reliable models.
- Rawlings Heart of the Hide
- Wilson A2000
- Easton Ghost
- Mizuno Prospect series
- Nokona Alpha
- Louisville Slugger Genesis
- Franklin Field Master
The above list comprises gloves that balance quality, durability, and affordability. Each of these gloves offers different features and benefits. Now, let’s explore these options in detail.
-
Rawlings Heart of the Hide: The Rawlings Heart of the Hide is a well-known model renowned for its craftsmanship. Made from high-quality leather, this glove develops a comfortable fit over time. Players appreciate its balance of performance and durability, making it ideal for both youth and adult leagues. Its distinctive color options also attract a diverse range of players.
-
Wilson A2000: The Wilson A2000 is popular among both professional and amateur players. It features pro-grade leather and a durable design. The glove’s Dual Welting technology offers better stability and shape retention. Players highlight its excellent grip and the comfort of its padding, making it suitable for long games.
-
Easton Ghost: Known for its lightweight design, the Easton Ghost glove is perfect for players who value speed and agility. It provides excellent flexibility, ensuring quick movements on the field. Also, its unique construction helps create a larger catching surface. Many youth players find it particularly appealing for fast pitch scenarios.
-
Mizuno Prospect series: The Mizuno Prospect series is specifically designed for younger players. It features a lightweight construction and a pocket that aids in catching. Parents and coaches appreciate its affordability and ease of use for beginners. The glove’s durability means it can withstand rigorous play without losing shape.
-
Nokona Alpha: The Nokona Alpha series includes gloves made from American-made leather. These gloves are known for their unique feel and ability to mold to players’ hands. Users report that Nokona gloves last longer than many competitors, making them a solid investment.
-
Louisville Slugger Genesis: The Louisville Slugger Genesis is recognized for its affordability and solid performance, making it suitable for both practice and games. Made from synthetic leather, it provides a lightweight option for players. This glove is commonly recommended for those new to the sport or playing in recreational leagues.
-
Franklin Field Master: The Franklin Field Master glove is designed for young or beginner players. It features a soft synthetic leather shell which helps players catch effectively. Its low price point and simple design make it one of the most accessible options for families looking for a first glove for their child.
Which Brands Are Most Recommended for Quality Used Baseball Gloves?
The most recommended brands for quality used baseball gloves include Rawlings, Wilson, Mizuno, Easton, and Louisville Slugger.
- Rawlings
- Wilson
- Mizuno
- Easton
- Louisville Slugger
Each brand has unique attributes that cater to different player needs and preferences, impacting their popularity and recommendations.
-
Rawlings:
Rawlings is synonymous with quality baseball gloves. The brand focuses on innovative designs and materials. Many players recommend Rawlings for its professional-grade craftsmanship and durability. The Rawlings Heart of the Hide series, for example, is a favorite among serious players due to its high-quality leather and fine workmanship. It is known for maintaining shape and performance over time, making them a solid choice on the second-hand market. -
Wilson:
Wilson is well-regarded for its technology and player-specific models. The brand produces gloves tailored to various positions, enhancing performance. The Wilson A2000 series is particularly noted for its patented dual welting and Pro Stock leather, which provide long-lasting quality. Many players appreciate Wilson for their customized glove options, though some opinions suggest their price point may be higher compared to others. -
Mizuno:
Mizuno gloves are celebrated for their comfort and fit. The brand uses specific technologies that enhance flexibility and control. Players often recommend Mizuno for their lightweight models, which allow for ease of movement. Specific lines, like the Mizuno Pro series, feature high-quality leather and are frequently praised for their durability while maintaining a soft feel. -
Easton:
Easton is recognized for its affordability paired with quality. It is a go-to brand for amateur players and younger athletes. Easton gloves are often recommended for their easy break-in period and overall performance value. While some pros use Easton gloves, the brand is generally viewed as more suitable for beginners and intermediate players. -
Louisville Slugger:
Louisville Slugger is esteemed for its classic designs and tradition in baseball equipment. Many players admire its handcrafted qualities. The brand’s gloves often combine vintage styles with modern technology, appealing to players who appreciate tradition. However, some users express concerns over availability and finding specific models on the second-hand market.
Each of these brands has distinctive characteristics, which influence player experience and choices in the used baseball glove market.
How Can You Properly Maintain a Used Baseball Glove for Longevity?
Proper maintenance of a used baseball glove enhances its longevity and performance through cleaning, conditioning, and proper storage. Consider these key maintenance steps:
-
Cleaning the Glove: Regularly remove dirt and debris.
– Use a damp cloth to wipe off any surface dirt. This prevents the accumulation of grime, which can damage the leather over time.
– For deeper cleans, consider using a glove-specific cleaner or a mild soap solution. Always ensure to rinse and dry adequately. -
Conditioning the Leather: Keep the leather soft and supple.
– Apply a leather conditioner every few months. This prevents the leather from drying out and cracking.
– Use a small amount of conditioner on a soft cloth and rub it in gently. Allow the glove to absorb the conditioner before using it again. -
Proper Storage: Store the glove correctly to maintain shape.
– Store the glove in a cool, dry place. Avoid leaving it in direct sunlight or inside a hot car, as heat can warp the leather.
– Keep the glove in a breathable bag or use a ball to help maintain its shape. Avoid tightly closing the glove without something inside, as this can lead to creases. -
Avoid Water Damage: Protect against moisture.
– Never submerge the glove in water. If it gets wet, gently blot it with a towel and let it air dry at room temperature.
– If the glove is soaked, use newspaper inside to maintain its shape while it dries. This prevents the leather from stiffening. -
Regular Use: Keep the glove game-ready.
– Occasional practice and game time help the glove maintain its flexibility. Regular use ensures that the glove conforms to the shape of your hand and the ball, improving performance. -
Repairs: Address wear and tear promptly.
– Inspect the glove for any signs of wear, such as loose stitching or cracks in the leather. Repair these issues quickly to prevent further damage.
– Consider professional repairing services if necessary, as they can restore the glove’s integrity.
By following these maintenance practices, you can significantly extend the life and usability of a used baseball glove.
Related Post: