best flat shoes for cycling

Unlike other models that struggle with grip and comfort, the Crankbrothers Flat, MTB Shoes, Black/Gum, 10.5 stood out after hands-on testing. Its Crankbrothers MC2 rubber compound provides excellent pedal contact and abrasion resistance, giving you confidence on steep descents and rough terrain. The lugged tread pattern and ramped toe offer superb traction both on and off the bike, making walking easier when needed. Plus, the cushioned EVA midsole absorbs shocks during intense rides, while breathable mesh panels keep your feet cool.

Compared to the Giro Tracker or Tommaso Comodo, this shoe shines in pedal connection and safety features. The heel dots and hidden eyelets boost grip and durability, and the Match system ensures a perfect fit with Crankbrothers pedals. It’s built tough but breathable, perfect for demanding trails or quick transitions to walking. This combination of grip, protection, and comfort makes it my top pick—trust me, your feet will thank you for choosing the Crankbrothers Flat, MTB Shoes for your cycling adventures.

Top Recommendation: Crankbrothers Flat, MTB Shoes, Black/Gum, 10.5

Why We Recommend It: This shoe excels with its durable Crankbrothers MC2 rubber compound offering superior grip. The tread pattern maximizes pedal contact while enhancing walkability, and the cushioned midsole delivers shock absorption during rough rides. Its ventilated design ensures airflow, and the Match system guarantees compatibility with Crankbrothers pedals. Compared to Giro or Tommaso, which focus on style or general support, the Crankbrothers shoe provides unmatched pedal grip and durability—making it the best choice for serious mountain biking.

Best flat shoes for cycling: Our Top 3 Picks

• Crankbrothers Flat, MTB Shoes, Black/Gum, 10.5 – Best flat shoes for cycling enthusiasts
• Tommaso Comodo MTB Shoes for Mens Mountain Bikes Flat – Best flat shoes for cycling comfort
• Giro Tracker Men BOA Flat Pedal Mountain Bike Shoes 2024 48 – Best flat pedal cycling shoes

What Should You Consider When Selecting Flat Shoes for Cycling?

When selecting flat shoes for cycling, several factors should be taken into account to ensure comfort, performance, and safety.

• Fit and Comfort: The fit of the shoe is crucial; it should be snug without causing discomfort. Look for shoes that allow for slight movement of the toes while providing enough support for long rides.
• Material and Breathability: The material of the shoes affects durability and breathability. Opt for shoes made from breathable fabrics or mesh to help keep your feet cool and dry during cycling.
• Sole Stiffness: A stiffer sole provides more efficient power transfer while pedaling. However, if you prioritize comfort over performance, a moderately stiff sole may be more suitable, especially for casual rides.
• Traction and Tread: Good traction is essential for safety, particularly when walking or dismounting. Look for shoes with rubber outsoles and a tread pattern that offers grip on various surfaces.
• Weight: Lightweight shoes can enhance your performance, making cycling less strenuous. Consider shoes that balance durability with a lightweight design to improve your overall cycling experience.
• Style and Versatility: If you plan to use your shoes off the bike as well, choose a style that transitions well to casual settings. Versatile designs allow you to wear them for other activities, making them a practical choice.
• Price and Value: Set a budget that reflects your cycling frequency and needs. Assess the value of the shoes based on their features, as investing in high-quality shoes can lead to better performance and durability.

What Materials Are Best for Durability and Comfort in Cycling Flat Shoes?

The best materials for durability and comfort in cycling flat shoes include the following:

• Leather: Leather is a classic choice for cycling shoes due to its excellent durability and ability to mold to the shape of the foot over time. It provides a natural feel and breathability, making it suitable for long rides, though it may require more maintenance compared to synthetic materials.
• Synthetic Mesh: Synthetic mesh is lightweight and highly breathable, making it ideal for warmer climates and providing a comfortable fit during extended rides. It often features moisture-wicking properties, which help keep the feet dry and reduce the risk of blisters.
• Gore-Tex: Gore-Tex is a waterproof and breathable material that is excellent for cycling in wet conditions. It prevents water from entering the shoe while allowing moisture from sweat to escape, ensuring that your feet remain dry and comfortable throughout your ride.
• Canvas: Canvas is a lightweight and flexible material that provides a casual feel while being durable enough for cycling. It is often used in flat shoes that prioritize style and comfort, making them a popular choice for urban cycling.
• Rubber Outsoles: Rubber outsoles are essential for providing traction and durability on various surfaces. They offer good grip, which enhances stability during rides, and are often designed to withstand wear from frequent use.
• Memory Foam: Memory foam insoles add an extra layer of comfort by conforming to the shape of the foot and providing cushioning. This feature is especially beneficial for long rides, as it helps reduce foot fatigue and discomfort.

How Do Closure Systems Impact Fit and Performance in Cycling Flat Shoes?

Closure systems significantly influence the fit and performance of cycling flat shoes, affecting how securely the shoe holds the foot during rides.

• Laces: Traditional laces offer a customizable fit, allowing riders to adjust tightness across the foot for optimal comfort and stability. However, they can sometimes become loose during rides, requiring periodic re-tightening, which may disrupt concentration.
• Velcro Straps: Velcro straps provide quick and convenient adjustments, making them ideal for riders who frequently take their shoes on and off. They can create a snug fit but may wear out over time, losing their ability to hold securely.
• BOA System: The BOA closure system uses a dial to tighten or loosen the shoe, providing a precise fit that can be adjusted on the fly. This system evenly distributes pressure across the foot, enhancing comfort and reducing the likelihood of hotspots during long rides.
• Slip-on Designs: Slip-on shoes emphasize ease of use and often feature elastic materials for a snug fit. While they are convenient, they may lack the same level of adjustability and support compared to traditional closure systems, potentially compromising performance on challenging terrains.
• Magnetic Closures: Magnetic closures offer a unique blend of ease and security, allowing for quick fastening while providing a firm hold. They are less common but can be highly effective in ensuring the shoe remains securely in place without the hassle of traditional methods.

What Are the Top Brands Known for Quality Flat Cycling Shoes?

The best flat shoes for cycling are known for their comfort, grip, and durability, making them suitable for various riding styles.

• Five Ten: Five Ten is renowned for its high-friction rubber soles that provide excellent grip on the pedals, making it a favorite among mountain bikers and casual cyclists alike. The brand’s designs typically prioritize comfort with a snug fit that allows for optimal pedaling efficiency.
• Giro: Giro offers a range of flat cycling shoes that balance style and performance, featuring lightweight materials and breathable designs. Their shoes often include a stiff sole for efficient power transfer, while still providing the comfort needed for long rides.
• Specialized: Specialized is well-known for its innovative cycling gear, and its flat shoes are no exception, providing a blend of performance and comfort. With features like a supportive footbed and durable construction, these shoes are designed to handle both on-road and off-road conditions effectively.
• Shimano: Shimano’s flat cycling shoes are designed with versatility in mind, catering to both mountain biking and casual rides. They often feature a grippy outsole and a comfortable fit, making them suitable for various biking activities, including commuting and recreational cycling.
• Pearl Izumi: Pearl Izumi offers flat shoes that emphasize comfort and a natural foot position, which can reduce fatigue during long rides. Their shoes typically feature a rugged outsole for traction and a sleek design that appeals to both performance-oriented cyclists and casual riders.

Which Brands Offer the Best Features for Flat Cycling Shoes?

The top brands known for offering the best features in flat cycling shoes include:

• Five Ten: Renowned for their superior grip and durability, Five Ten shoes often feature Stealth rubber soles, which provide exceptional traction on flat pedals. They are designed with comfort in mind, often incorporating cushioning and support for lengthy rides.
• Giro: Giro flat cycling shoes focus on a balance of performance and style, with breathable materials that enhance comfort during rides. Their outsole design promotes efficient power transfer while maintaining the flexibility needed for walking off the bike.
• Crankbrothers: Known for their innovative design, Crankbrothers shoes often come with a unique sole pattern that enhances grip on flat pedals. They prioritize lightweight construction and comfort, making them ideal for both cycling and casual wear.
• Specialized: Specialized offers flat cycling shoes that combine performance and versatility, featuring specialized rubber compounds for optimal pedal grip. Their shoes are designed with a focus on fit and comfort, often incorporating ergonomic features to support the foot during extended rides.
• Shimano: Shimano’s flat cycling shoes are built with advanced materials that provide durability and breathability, ensuring comfort in various conditions. They offer a solid grip on the pedals and are designed for both cycling performance and casual use, making them a versatile choice for riders.

How Do Different Styles of Flat Shoes Suit Various Cycling Disciplines?

Different styles of flat shoes cater to various cycling disciplines, enhancing performance and comfort based on the specific demands of each activity.

• Mountain Biking Shoes: These shoes typically feature a rugged sole with deep lugs for optimal grip on uneven terrain. They often have reinforced toe caps and are made from durable materials to withstand harsh conditions, providing both protection and traction on trails.
• Casual Cycling Shoes: Designed for leisurely rides, these shoes prioritize comfort and style over performance. They often have a more flexible sole and a casual appearance, making them suitable for riders who may also wear them off the bike, perfect for urban commuting or recreational cycling.
• Bikepacking Shoes: These shoes are versatile, designed for long-distance rides that may involve walking or hiking. They typically offer a balance between stiffness for pedaling efficiency and comfort for walking, featuring a sole that accommodates hiking in rugged terrain while still being efficient on the bike.
• Touring Shoes: Ideal for long rides, touring shoes are built for comfort and support during extended periods of cycling. They often include features like padding and breathable materials, along with a sole that provides enough grip for both pedaling and occasional walking.
• BMX Shoes: Generally more casual in style, BMX shoes are crafted to provide excellent grip on the pedals and durability for tricks and jumps. They usually feature a flat, sticky rubber sole that enhances pedal feel and control, catering specifically to the demands of BMX riding.
• Urban Cycling Shoes: These shoes are tailored for city riding, combining elements of style with functionality. They often have a sleek design and may include reflective materials for safety, while the soles are designed for good grip and comfort, making them suitable for navigating busy streets.

What Styles Are Preferable for Mountain Biking Versus Casual Riding?

Style	Purpose	Grip	Comfort	Weight	Breathability	Examples
Mountain Biking Shoes	Designed for rugged trails and technical terrain.	Features aggressive tread for optimal traction on loose surfaces.	Typically stiffer for better power transfer while pedaling.	Generally heavier for durability and protection.	Often have ventilation features for hot conditions.	Brands like Five Ten, Shimano, and Giro.
Casual Riding Shoes	Ideal for city riding and leisurely trips.	Often have a smoother sole for versatility on pavement.	Focus on comfort and ease of walking off the bike.	Lighter for ease of mobility.	Usually more breathable materials for comfort.	Brands like Vans, Adidas, and Merrell.

What Advantages Do Flat Shoes Offer Over Clipless Shoes for Cycling?

Flat shoes provide several advantages over clipless shoes for cycling, making them a popular choice among various cyclists.

• Ease of Use: Flat shoes are straightforward to put on and take off, as they require no additional clips or pedals.

This feature is particularly beneficial for casual cyclists or those who may need to stop frequently, such as commuting or running errands. The simplicity of slipping on flat shoes allows for quick transitions between cycling and walking.

• Versatility: Flat shoes can be used for a variety of activities beyond cycling, including walking and casual outings.

This versatility makes them an attractive option for cyclists who may not want to invest in a separate pair of shoes for everyday use. Furthermore, flat shoes tend to be designed in styles that are more socially acceptable off the bike.

• Comfort: Many flat shoes are designed with comfort in mind, often featuring cushioned soles and breathable materials.

This can lead to a more enjoyable riding experience, especially on longer rides or during hot weather. Additionally, the absence of rigid cleats allows for a more natural foot position, reducing discomfort during extended periods of cycling.

• Control and Stability: Flat shoes provide direct contact with the pedal surface, enhancing stability and control during rides.

Riders can easily shift their foot position for optimal power transfer or comfort, which can be particularly advantageous in technical riding scenarios or when navigating challenging terrain. This control can lead to improved handling and confidence on the bike.

• Safety: In the event of a fall or sudden stop, flat shoes allow for easier disengagement from the pedals.

This can significantly reduce the risk of injury that may occur with clipless systems, where the rider may struggle to unclip in a moment of panic. The ability to quickly step off the bike can be reassuring for less experienced cyclists or those riding in busy environments.

How Do Flat Shoes Enhance Comfort for Recreational Cyclists?

Flat shoes can significantly enhance comfort for recreational cyclists by providing stability, support, and flexibility during rides.

• Stability: Flat shoes offer a broad, flat sole that helps distribute weight evenly across the foot, which can enhance balance and control while pedaling. This stability is particularly beneficial for cyclists who prefer a more natural foot position without the constraints of clipless pedals.
• Comfortable Fit: Many flat cycling shoes are designed with a more relaxed fit compared to traditional cycling shoes, allowing for greater comfort during prolonged rides. This can reduce pressure points and blisters, making them ideal for casual cyclists who may not ride for long periods.
• Breathability: Flat shoes often feature breathable materials that help keep feet cool and dry, which is essential for maintaining comfort during warmer rides. Good ventilation can prevent overheating and excessive sweating, contributing to a more enjoyable cycling experience.
• Versatility: Flat shoes can be worn off the bike as well, making them a practical choice for recreational cyclists who may want to transition from cycling to walking or other activities. This multi-functionality allows for seamless movement between cycling and daily life without the need to change footwear.
• Flexibility: The flexible design of flat shoes allows for a natural range of motion in the foot, which can enhance pedaling efficiency and comfort. This flexibility is important for recreational cyclists who may not require the stiffer soles associated with performance cycling shoes, allowing for a more relaxed and enjoyable ride.

What Do Cyclists Say About Their Experiences with Different Flat Shoes?

• Comfort: Many cyclists emphasize the importance of comfort in flat shoes, particularly for long rides. Shoes with ample cushioning and a good fit help prevent foot fatigue and allow for a more enjoyable cycling experience.
• Grip: Cyclists frequently mention the significance of grip when selecting flat shoes. Shoes designed with rubber outsoles provide better traction on the pedal, ensuring stability and control during rides, especially in varied weather conditions.
• Breathability: Breathability is another key factor that cyclists highlight. Shoes made from lightweight, breathable materials help keep feet cool and dry, which is essential for longer rides where moisture buildup can lead to discomfort.
• Durability: Durability is a common topic among cyclists discussing flat shoes. Shoes constructed with high-quality materials can withstand the wear and tear of cycling, making them a worthwhile investment for regular riders.
• Style: Many cyclists also consider the aesthetic appeal of their flat shoes. A stylish design can enhance their overall cycling outfit, and some brands offer a range of colors and styles that appeal to different tastes while maintaining functionality.

What Common Complaints Do Cyclists Have About Flat Cycling Shoes?

• Insufficient Stiffness: Many cyclists find that flat shoes lack the necessary stiffness for efficient power transfer during pedaling. Unlike clipless shoes, which have stiffer soles, flat shoes can lead to a feeling of energy loss with each stroke, making it harder to maintain speed and control.
• Poor Grip: Some cyclists report that the grip of flat shoes on pedals can be inadequate, especially in wet or muddy conditions. This can lead to slippage, reducing confidence and safety while riding, particularly on technical trails or steep descents.
• Limited Comfort: Comfort can be a significant issue, as flat cycling shoes may not provide enough arch support or cushioning for longer rides. Riders often experience discomfort or pain in their feet, which can distract from the enjoyment of cycling.
• Weight: A common complaint is that many flat cycling shoes are heavier than their clipless counterparts. The added weight can make a noticeable difference, particularly for competitive cyclists or those looking to maximize performance on longer rides.
• Style and Versatility: Some cyclists feel that flat cycling shoes lack the stylish design or versatility of other footwear options. This can be a concern for those who want to wear their cycling shoes off the bike without sacrificing aesthetics.

How Can You Maintain Your Cycling Flat Shoes for Long-Lasting Use?

To ensure your cycling flat shoes last longer and perform optimally, consider the following maintenance tips:

• Regular Cleaning: Keeping your flat shoes clean is essential for maintaining their appearance and functionality. Use a soft brush or damp cloth to remove dirt and debris after every ride, and for deeper cleans, you can use mild soap and water, avoiding harsh chemicals that could damage materials.
• Proper Drying: After a ride, especially in wet conditions, allow your shoes to dry properly to prevent mold and odor. Always dry them at room temperature, avoiding direct sunlight or heat sources, which can warp the materials and compromise their integrity.
• Inspecting for Wear: Regularly check for signs of wear, such as frayed stitching, sole separation, or worn-out rubber. Addressing these issues early can prolong the life of your shoes; for instance, you can re-glue parts that are coming apart or replace laces that have become frayed.
• Using Protective Sprays: Applying a water-repellent spray can protect your cycling shoes from moisture and stains. Ensure the spray is suitable for the material of your shoes and follow the manufacturer’s instructions for application.
• Storing Properly: Store your flat shoes in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and heat when not in use. Using shoe trees or stuffing them with newspaper can help maintain their shape and absorb moisture.
• Rotating Shoes: If you cycle frequently, consider owning multiple pairs of flat shoes. Rotating them allows each pair time to rest and breathe, reducing wear and tear and extending their lifespan.

What Cleaning Practices Should You Follow for Optimal Shoe Care?

To ensure optimal shoe care for the best flat shoes for cycling, several cleaning practices are essential:

• Regular Brushing: Use a soft-bristled brush to remove dirt and debris from the surface of your shoes.
• Spot Cleaning: For stains or marks, apply a mild detergent with water and a cloth to gently scrub the affected area.
• Washing the Insoles: Take out the insoles and wash them separately to eliminate odors and bacteria.
• Air Drying: Always allow your shoes to air dry naturally away from direct sunlight or heat sources.
• Conditioning Materials: Use appropriate conditioners for leather or synthetic materials to keep them supple and prevent cracking.

Regular brushing helps maintain the appearance of your cycling shoes by preventing the buildup of grime that can wear down materials over time. Be sure to use a brush that is soft enough to avoid scratching or damaging the shoe’s surface.

Spot cleaning is effective for addressing specific stains; it’s important to use a mild detergent mixed with water and a soft cloth to avoid damaging the shoe’s fabric or finish. This method allows for targeted cleaning without subjecting the entire shoe to unnecessary moisture.

Washing the insoles is crucial for hygiene, as they can absorb sweat and odors. Remove them from the shoes, and wash them with a gentle detergent and water, ensuring they are thoroughly dried before reinserting them.

Air drying is essential for preserving the shoe’s structure and materials. Avoid placing them in direct sunlight or near heaters, as excessive heat can warp the shoes or damage their components.

Conditioning materials such as leather or specific synthetics helps maintain their flexibility and appearance. Using the right products ensures that the material does not dry out or crack, extending the life of your shoes.

Related Post:

• Best cycling fish
• Best cycling gloves for carpal tunnel syndrome
• Best cycling first aid kit
• Best vented cycling helmet
• Best cycling face mask