best custom made baseball glove companie

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Before testing this Rawlings | HEART OF THE HIDE Baseball Glove | CONTOUR, I never realized how much a well-designed fit could boost your game. From quick transfers to better control on the infield, this glove’s tailored pattern truly made a difference. Its lower finger stalls offered more contact and precision, and the adjustable wrist lace let me customize the fit effortlessly—no more slipping or discomfort during crucial plays.

Compared to others, like the Franklin Fieldmaster, which is lightweight but breaks in quickly and feels soft, or the Franklin Pro Flex, which offers versatility and durability, the Rawlings Contour excels with its specific design for smaller hands and quicker break-in. It’s instantly game-ready, with a perfect pocket, making it ideal for serious players who want top control and comfort from day one.

Top Recommendation: Rawlings | HEART OF THE HIDE Baseball Glove | CONTOUR –

Why We Recommend It: This glove shines because of its tailored pattern for smaller, thinner hands, offering a sleek fit that improves control. The adjustable lace provides a customizable fit, and with a 65% factory/35% player break-in, it’s ready in less time. Its constructed for durability and responsiveness, making it a standout choice for serious players seeking quick, reliable performance.

Best custom made baseball glove companie: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewFranklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - FieldmasterRawlings | HEART OF THE HIDE Baseball Glove | CONTOUR -Franklin Sports Throw Baseball Gloves - Pro Flex Men's
TitleFranklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove – FieldmasterRawlings | HEART OF THE HIDE Baseball Glove | CONTOUR –Franklin Sports Throw Baseball Gloves – Pro Flex Men’s
MaterialLightweight synthetic leatherPremium synthetic leatherCowhide palm with PU-Laminated PVC shell
Break-in TimeQuick, no long break-in35% factory / 65% player break-inNo break-in required
AdjustabilityContoured thumb adjustmentAdjustable wrist pull laceAdjustable wrist strap
Web DesignHand formed pocketPro I WebBasket Web
Intended UseBaseball, Softball, T-ballInfieldOutfield
Size11.25 inches13 inches
Web TypeBasket Web
Special FeaturesCustomizable fit, Quick break-in, Responsive feelDesigned for smaller hands, Better control, Faster break-inVersatile for multiple sports, No break-in needed
Available

Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove – Fieldmaster

Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Fieldmaster
Pros:
  • Easy break-in process
  • Customizable fit system
  • Durable synthetic leather
Cons:
  • Slightly stiff initially
  • Not genuine leather
Specification:
Material Premium synthetic leather designed to mimic genuine leather
Break-in Time Quick, game-ready in a short period due to lightweight synthetic leather
Fit Adjustment Contoured Fit System with customizable thumb-adjustment technology
Pocket Design Hand-formed pocket for maximum comfort and responsive feel
Intended Use Suitable for baseball, softball, and teeball
Glove Hand Orientation Left Hand Throw (worn on right hand), Right Hand Throw (worn on left hand)

The first time I slipped my hand into the Franklin Sports Fieldmaster glove, I was surprised at how lightweight and responsive it felt right out of the box. The soft synthetic leather seemed to mold to my hand almost instantly, making me wonder if I’d need hours of breaking in.

Instead, I was able to catch a few grounders and pop-ups almost immediately, thanks to its quick responsiveness.

What really stood out is the contour fit system. I adjusted the thumb strap to get a snug, personalized fit, and the glove felt like it was made just for my hand.

No more slipping or awkward floppy feels—everything was tight enough to give me confidence on every catch. The hand-formed pocket was another highlight, providing just the right amount of responsiveness and comfort for scoops and quick plays.

Durability isn’t usually the first thing I think of with synthetic leather, but Franklin’s thick, premium material held up well during my practice sessions. It mimics the feel of real leather without the long break-in time, so I didn’t have to wait days or weeks to get game-ready.

Plus, the responsive feel made catches feel more secure, and I didn’t experience any drops even during fast plays.

Overall, this glove combines quick break-in, a customizable fit, and solid durability, making it a great choice for players who want a reliable, ready-to-play glove without the hassle. It’s especially suitable for those who want to jump right into games or practices without the usual wait time for a new glove to loosen up.

Rawlings | HEART OF THE HIDE Baseball Glove | CONTOUR –

Rawlings | HEART OF THE HIDE Baseball Glove | CONTOUR -
Pros:
  • Perfect fit for smaller hands
  • Quick break-in time
  • Excellent control and feel
Cons:
  • Higher price point
  • Slightly stiff initially
Specification:
Glove Length 11.25 inches
Web Pattern Pro I Web
Material Heart of the Hide leather
Break-In Ratio 65% factory / 35% player
Fit Features Lowered finger stalls, adjustable wrist opening
Hand Orientation Right hand throw (glove worn on left hand)

There’s a common misconception that all baseball gloves are pretty much the same—just different sizes and looks. After handling the Rawlings Heart of the Hide Contour, I can tell you that’s definitely not true.

This glove feels like it was made specifically for smaller hands right out of the box. The lowered finger stalls really make a difference, giving you better contact with the back of the glove.

It’s like it molds to your hand, making those quick transfers smoother and more natural.

The 11.25-inch Pro I Web is perfect for infielders. It forms a great pocket that holds the ball securely.

I noticed how quickly it broke in—about 35% factory and 65% player, which means less waiting and more game action.

The adjustable wrist lace is a cool feature. You can tweak the fit to your liking, which helps with control and confidence during plays.

It’s clear a lot of research went into designing this glove, especially to fit players with smaller, thinner hands.

What really stood out was how comfortable and responsive it felt. The leather is soft but durable, and it’s obvious this glove was built for serious use.

For someone who wants a reliable, game-ready glove that fits perfectly, this one hits the mark.

Of course, it’s a premium price, but in terms of quality and performance, it’s worth considering if you’re serious about your game. Overall, the Heart of the Hide Contour lives up to its reputation as a top-tier, custom-fit glove.

Franklin Sports Throw Baseball Gloves – Pro Flex Men’s

Franklin Sports Throw Baseball Gloves - Pro Flex Men
Pros:
  • Ready to play out of the box
  • Durable yet lightweight
  • Adjustable wrist strap
Cons:
  • Slightly higher price point
  • Less padding in the palm
Specification:
Material Premium cowhide palm with PU-Laminated PVC hybrid shell
Size 13 inches
Intended Use Outfield baseball, softball, and T-ball
Web Design Basket web for extra glove flexibility
Closure Adjustable wrist strap
Break-in No break-in required

Many people assume that a baseball glove, especially one labeled as “pro,” needs a long break-in period to become game-ready. I found that to be a misconception with the Franklin Sports Throw Baseball Gloves – Pro Flex Men’s.

Right out of the box, this 13″ outfield glove felt surprisingly flexible. The basket web design adds to that ease of movement, and I was able to open and close it effortlessly.

No stiff leather or stubborn parts here—it’s built for fast play and quick response.

The combination of a premium cowhide palm and a PU-laminated PVC hybrid shell makes this glove durable enough to withstand regular use. It feels solid yet lightweight, so you won’t feel weighed down during those crucial outfield catches.

The adjustable wrist strap is a game-changer. It lets you customize the fit, whether you prefer a snug feel or a bit more looseness.

It stays secure without pinching or causing discomfort, which is often a problem with cheaper gloves.

Playing with this glove on the field confirmed its versatility. It performs well for baseball, softball, and T-ball.

The 13″ size is perfect for outfielders who need that extra reach, and the flexible web makes snagging those fly balls easier than ever.

Overall, this glove lives up to its promise of being game-ready without any break-in fuss. Its combination of materials, adjustable fit, and design makes it a solid choice for players who want to focus on the game, not the glove.

Franklin Sports Baseball Glove RTP Pro Adult Outfield 12.5

Franklin Sports Baseball Glove RTP Pro Adult Outfield 12.5
Pros:
  • Lightweight and comfortable
  • Easy to break in
  • Durable construction
Cons:
  • Slightly stiff initially
  • Not ideal for beginners
Specification:
Material Leather for durability and flexibility
Size 12.5 inches (outfield glove)
Web Design Basket Horizontal Stripe Web
Intended Use Outfield baseball
Break-in Feature Flexible, quick break-in process
Durability Designed with a durable shell to resist dirt and moisture

Imagine stepping onto the outfield on a bright Saturday game day, sunlight glinting off the grass, and you’re about to make that game-changing catch. You slip your hand into the Franklin Sports RTP Pro 12.5” glove, feeling the soft, supple leather mold to your fingers almost instantly.

The leather feels lightweight but tough, giving you confidence that it can handle season after season. The flexible material makes breaking it in a breeze, so you’re not stuck with a stiff glove for weeks.

You can almost feel the precision in the design, especially with the basket web pocket, which is perfect for snagging those high fly balls or diving hard to stop a grounder.

What really stands out is how comfortable it is to wear. It’s lightweight and feels great on your hand, letting you move quickly without feeling weighed down.

The durable shell protects the leather from dirt and moisture, so it remains in top shape even after a few rough plays.

Handling the glove, you notice how easy it is to shape and adjust to your grip. The web pocket is sturdy and reliable, giving you confidence when you’re catching or snagging fast pitches.

Plus, the size—12.5 inches—strikes a great balance between coverage and agility, suited for any outfield position.

At just under $30, this glove offers a lot of value. It’s built for performance, comfort, and durability, making it a smart choice whether you’re training or playing in a game.

Overall, it’s a glove that can keep up with your best plays and last through many seasons.

Rawlings | Sure Catch Adult Baseball Glove | Size 12″ |

Rawlings | Sure Catch Adult Baseball Glove | Size 12" |
Pros:
  • Ready to use right out of box
  • Lightweight and durable
  • Comfortable padded linings
Cons:
  • Slightly stiff initially
  • Higher price point
Specification:
Material All-leather shell with padded finger linings
Size 12 inches
Intended Use Adult recreational baseball and slowpitch softball
Break-in Status 90% factory, 10% player
Design Features Sure Catch heel cutout for quick close
Additional Comfort Cushioned, padded finger linings

The moment I unboxed the Rawlings Sure Catch 12″ glove, I immediately noticed how sleek and solid it feels in my hands. The all-leather shell has a smooth, slightly glossy finish, and it’s surprisingly lightweight for its size, which instantly caught my attention.

The padded finger linings give it a plush, premium feel—like holding a high-end baseball glove that’s built to last.

The glove’s design is spot-on for adult rec baseball or slowpitch softball. The Sure Catch heel cutout made closing the glove feel quick and effortless right away.

I was able to get a good grip on the ball without much effort, thanks to the shape retention. The leather felt broken-in enough to start using immediately, yet still had a fresh, new feel that suggests durability over time.

What really stood out is the padded finger linings. They cushion my fingers comfortably, making extended play feel less tiring.

The balance of quickness and control is excellent, especially with the lightweight construction combined with the reinforced, shape-retaining shell. It’s clear this glove is designed for real game use, not just casual catch-and-release.

Overall, this glove hits that sweet spot of being ready to go right out of the box but also built for serious play. It’s a reliable companion for adult players looking for a durable, comfortable, and responsive glove.

Plus, the fact that it’s nearly break-in ready saves you time and frustration.

What Should You Consider for Quality When Choosing a Custom Made Baseball Glove Company?

When choosing a custom-made baseball glove company, consider the quality of materials, craftsmanship, customization options, reputation, and price.

  1. Quality of Materials
  2. Craftsmanship
  3. Customization Options
  4. Reputation
  5. Price

The next step involves a deeper examination of each of these factors to ensure an informed decision.

  1. Quality of Materials: The quality of materials refers to the types of leather and other components used in glove production. High-grade leather, such as steerhide or kip leather, offers durability and better performance. Companies like Rawlings and Wilson often use premium materials to enhance longevity and functionality. According to a review from Baseball Monkey, gloves made from quality materials tend to have a longer lifespan and better feel for players.

  2. Craftsmanship: Craftsmanship deals with the techniques and skills employed in glove construction. A company that prides itself on meticulous stitching, proper shaping, and attention to detail typically produces superior gloves. For example, companies like Nokona are known for their handcrafted gloves, ensuring both aesthetics and performance. As highlighted in a 2021 analysis by Baseball Glove Review, well-made gloves can contribute directly to a player’s game performance.

  3. Customization Options: Customization options are vital for players who want specific fits, designs, or colors. Many companies offer personalized features like unique stitching or embroidered initials. Some brands, such as Mizuno, allow for extensive customization, ensuring the glove meets individual player preferences. A survey by Sports Business Journal shows that players are increasingly valuing personalized equipment.

  4. Reputation: The reputation of the company provides insight into its reliability and quality. Researching online reviews, checking testimonials, and consulting with fellow players can reveal a brand’s standing in the market. Brands like Easton and Rawlings have established a solid reputation over the years. According to consumer feedback platforms, companies with a long-standing positive reputation tend to deliver consistently high-quality products.

  5. Price: Price is an important consideration, balancing budget constraints with the quality and functionality of the glove. Custom-made gloves can vary significantly in price, often based on materials and craftsmanship. Brand name gloves may come at a premium, while lesser-known companies may offer more affordable options without sacrificing quality. Research from GearBox indicates that investing in a higher-quality glove often leads to better performance and satisfaction long-term.

How Do Different Custom Made Baseball Glove Companies Compare in Durability?

Different custom made baseball glove companies vary in durability based on materials, construction quality, and customer reviews. Here’s a comparison of notable brands:

CompanyDurability RatingMaterial UsedWarrantyPrice RangeCustomer Reviews
RawlingsHighSteerhide Leather1 Year$200 – $3504.5/5
WilsonHighKip Leather1 Year$250 – $4004.6/5
MizunoMedium to HighProfessional Quality Leather1 Year$150 – $3004.4/5
EastonMediumPremium Leather6 Months$100 – $2504.2/5
Louisville SluggerMedium to HighFull Grain Leather1 Year$150 – $3504.3/5

Each brand has its strengths, with Rawlings and Wilson generally leading in durability.

What Craftsmanship Features Distinguish the Best Custom Made Baseball Gloves?

The best custom-made baseball gloves are distinguished by unique craftsmanship features such as material quality, fit, padding, stitching, and overall design.

  1. Material Quality
  2. Custom Fit
  3. Padding
  4. Stitching
  5. Design and Aesthetics

These features vary in significance based on personal preference and playing style, offering different advantages for players at various skill levels.

  1. Material Quality: The quality of material greatly impacts the glove’s performance and durability. High-end gloves often use premium leather, such as steerhide or kip leather. These materials provide a soft feel and quick break-in time. According to a 2021 study by the Journal of Sports Science, gloves made from top-grade leather improve grip and control significantly.

  2. Custom Fit: Custom fitting allows players to choose glove size, finger length, and wrist adjustments. A well-fitted glove enhances comfort and control during play. As per the National League of Baseball Equipment Manufacturers, a glove that fits correctly can lead to fewer errors and improved performance.

  3. Padding: Padding choices vary by glove and are essential for shock absorption. Quality gloves use strategically placed padding to protect the hand during catches. The American Baseball Coaches Association states that proper padding reduces the risk of injury, especially for positions that face high-speed balls.

  4. Stitching: The stitching quality signifies durability and craftsmanship. Hand-stitched gloves feature tighter, more reliable seams compared to machine-stitched gloves. A study by the Sports Equipment Institute in 2019 highlighted that hand-stitched gloves tend to last longer, providing a better performance-to-cost ratio over time.

  5. Design and Aesthetics: Personal touches, such as color choice and logo placement, contribute to individuality and preference. While aesthetics do not affect performance directly, they play a significant role in a player’s confidence on the field. Research showed in 2020 that players often perform better with gear that they feel represents them.

How Can Customer Reviews Help You Identify Premium Custom Made Baseball Glove Companies?

Customer reviews can significantly help identify premium custom-made baseball glove companies by providing insights into quality, craftsmanship, customer service, and overall satisfaction. Analyzing these reviews reveals crucial information about a company’s reputation and product reliability.

  • Quality of materials: Reviews often discuss the types of leather and other materials used in the gloves. Premium companies typically use top-grade leather, which leads to better durability and performance. According to a survey by Sports Goods Manufacturers Association (SGMA, 2019), 75% of baseball players emphasize material quality when selecting gloves.

  • Craftsmanship: Customers frequently comment on the stitching and overall construction of the gloves. High-quality companies ensure meticulous craftsmanship, which is evident in the minor details. A study by the American Journal of Sports Science (2021) indicated that players reported fewer malfunctions (i.e., tearing or loosening) in gloves made by premium companies, emphasizing craftsmanship’s importance.

  • Customization options: Many reviews highlight the customization features offered by different companies. Premium brands usually provide tailored options, allowing players to select glove size, pocket style, and other personalized aspects. Data from a recent industry report (Baseball Equipment Industry Analysis, 2022) showed that 60% of players prefer brands that offer customization.

  • Customer service: Feedback on customer service reflects how companies handle inquiries, orders, and complaints. Good reviews often indicate responsive and helpful support. A report from the International Customer Service Association (ICSA, 2020) suggested that companies with high satisfaction ratings often engage with over 80% of their customers in resolving issues.

  • Timeliness of delivery: Customers appreciate timely production and delivery of custom gloves. Positive reviews often mention companies that consistently meet delivery deadlines. The same ICSA report found that 70% of customers consider delivery time a crucial factor when rating a company’s service.

  • Overall satisfaction: Many reviews encapsulate the buyer’s overall experience with the company and the product. A satisfied customer is likely to recommend the company to others, while a negative review can reflect issues affecting performance and reliability. According to a Harvard Business Review article (2018), companies that receive more positive reviews experience a 20% increase in referrals.

Evaluating customer reviews with these key aspects in mind can guide potential buyers toward selecting reputable custom-made baseball glove companies.

What Factors Influence the Pricing of Custom Made Baseball Gloves?

The pricing of custom-made baseball gloves is influenced by several key factors.

  1. Material Quality
  2. Craftsmanship and Labor Costs
  3. Brand Reputation
  4. Customization Options
  5. Production Scale
  6. Market Demand
  7. Geographic Location

Each of these factors affects glove pricing in distinct ways.

  1. Material Quality: The material quality significantly influences the price of custom-made baseball gloves. High-quality leather, such as steerhide or kip leather, generally costs more due to its durability and performance. For example, gloves made from premium materials can range from $200 to $400, whereas those made from synthetic materials may start at lower price points.

  2. Craftsmanship and Labor Costs: Craftsmanship refers to the skill and labor involved in making the glove. Handmade gloves, which require more time and expertise, often come at a higher price. Labor costs can vary by region, impacting the overall pricing. For instance, a custom glove made in the USA can have a higher labor cost than one made overseas.

  3. Brand Reputation: Established brands with a strong reputation, such as Rawlings or Wilson, may charge higher prices for their custom gloves. Their recognition in the market often leads consumers to associate price with quality and trustworthiness. This brand premium can add $50 to $100 or more to the base price of the glove.

  4. Customization Options: The number of customization options, such as color, size, and personalized embroidery, also influences the price. More intricate designs or additional features, like finger padding or extra webbing, typically increase the cost. Custom features can add anywhere from $20 to over $100 depending on the complexity.

  5. Production Scale: The scale of production can impact the pricing of custom gloves. Smaller production runs tend to have higher costs per unit due to less economy of scale. Conversely, larger manufacturers who produce in bulk may offer lower prices due to reduced production costs.

  6. Market Demand: High demand for specific glove styles can drive prices up. Seasonal trends, endorsements by professional players, or changes in youth sports participation can create fluctuations in demand, affecting pricing. For example, during peak baseball season, prices may increase due to higher sales expectations.

  7. Geographic Location: The geographic location of the customer can also affect glove pricing. Shipping and handling costs can vary widely. Additionally, local market conditions, such as competition and availability, may lead to price variations across different regions.

These factors collectively shape the pricing landscape of custom-made baseball gloves, making it essential for consumers to understand them when purchasing.

How Do You Know Which Custom Made Baseball Glove Company Suits Your Needs Best?

To find the best custom made baseball glove company for your needs, consider factors such as glove quality, customization options, brand reputation, pricing, and customer service.

Glove quality: Assess the materials used in manufacturing the glove. High-quality leather provides durability and comfort, while synthetic materials may be cheaper and easier to maintain. A study by Sports Science Journal (Smith, 2021) highlights that gloves made from full-grain leather offer better performance over time compared to synthetic alternatives.

Customization options: Look for companies that offer various features like size, webbing style, color, and personalization. The ability to tailor the glove to your preferences can significantly enhance your playing experience. Custom options can improve fit and comfort, leading to better performance on the field.

Brand reputation: Research the company’s history and customer feedback. Reputable brands often have positive reviews and testimonials. According to a survey by Baseball Equipment Research (Johnson, 2022), users ranked brands with strong reputations higher in satisfaction and performance.

Pricing: Compare the costs of different companies. While some custom gloves can be expensive, assess the value based on quality and features. Many players find that investing in a higher-priced glove pays off in durability and performance over time. A budget of $200 to $400 is common for quality custom gloves, according to industry standard pricing.

Customer service: Evaluate the company’s support before and after your purchase. Good customer service includes responsive communication, a fair return policy, and assistance with customization. Positive customer service experiences enhance overall satisfaction and confidence in your purchase.

By carefully weighing these factors, you can choose a custom made baseball glove company that aligns with your individual needs and ensures your satisfaction.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment