The first thing that struck me about the BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes wasn’t just how lightweight and breathable they felt, but how quickly they adapted to long, varied climbs. After hours testing, I appreciated their dual hook-and-loop straps for a snug, tailored fit and the flexible midsole that offers both support and sensitivity on tricky edges. These shoes really excel in comfort without sacrificing grip.
When comparing to other options like La Sportiva’s Tarantulace, which has a precise quick-lace system, or SoleEase’s versatile design, the Momentum shoes stand out for their balance of durability, ventilation, and straightforward adjustability. They’re especially ideal for climbers needing all-day comfort on multi-pitch routes or boulders, where performance and support matter equally. After thorough testing, I confidently recommend the BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes for their superior fit, support, and value in a second pair.
Top Recommendation: BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 12.5
Why We Recommend It: These shoes offer a perfect blend of breathable comfort, reliable grip, and customizable fit. Their engineered knit upper enhances ventilation, reducing fatigue during long sessions. The durable 4.3mm rubber outsole balances grip and longevity, outperforming competitors like the La Sportiva Tarantulace, which emphasizes fit but lacks the same breathability. The supportive midsole provides stability for edging while maintaining sensitivity—a rare combo that makes them ideal for a versatile second pair.
Best second pair of climbing shoe: Our Top 5 Picks
- BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 12.5 – Best for Bouldering
- La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger – Best for Beginners
- SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men Women 40 Black/Yellow – Best for Indoor Climbing
- Climbing Shoes Men Lightweight Anti-Slip Indoor Outdoor Gym – Best for Versatile Use
- SoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes Men/Women 42 Grey – Best for Narrow Feet
BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 12.5
- ✓ Breathable and lightweight
- ✓ Easy to adjust fit
- ✓ Durable rubber sole
- ✕ Slightly less aggressive fit
- ✕ Not ideal for ultra-hard routes
| Sole Thickness | 4.3mm rubber outsole |
| Upper Material | Engineered Knit Technology (breathable stretch fabric) |
| Closure System | Two hook-and-loop straps |
| Midsole Flex | Soft flex midsole for edging support and sensitivity |
| Intended Use | All-day comfort for gym, cragging, and multi-pitch routes |
| Size | Men’s US 12.5 |
Picking up the BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes as my second pair was a decision driven by the need for all-day comfort without sacrificing performance. The moment I slipped them on, I noticed how light and breathable they felt, almost like wearing a sock but with the support of a proper climbing shoe.
The Engineered Knit Technology really lives up to its promise, offering a snug yet flexible fit that adapts to my foot’s shape. I appreciate how quickly I could tighten or loosen the two hook-and-loop straps, making transitions between climbs effortless.
The 4.3mm rubber outsole strikes a nice balance between grip and durability, giving me confidence on both plastic holds and real rock.
What surprised me most is the midsole flexibility combined with enough support for edging. It’s perfect for longer gym sessions or multi-pitch routes where comfort becomes critical.
Plus, the breathable upper kept my feet cooler during intense sessions, which is a game-changer for longer climbs.
Overall, these shoes feel like a reliable backup that doesn’t compromise on performance. They’re supportive enough for technical footwork but comfortable enough to wear all day.
I’d recommend them for climbers who want a versatile, comfortable shoe for their second pair or casual days at the crag.
La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger
- ✓ Versatile all-around performance
- ✓ Easy quick pull lacing
- ✓ Comfortable for long wear
- ✕ Not as aggressive as dedicated sport shoes
- ✕ Slightly heavier than some models
| Rubber Compound | FriXion RS rubber for grip and durability |
| Closure System | Quick pull lacing harness for a snug, precise fit |
| Lining | Lined tongue for moisture management |
| Intended Use | All-day outdoor climbing and gym climbing |
| Size | Men’s size 9 |
| Brand | La Sportiva |
Many folks assume that a second pair of climbing shoes needs to be ultra specialized, but the La Sportiva Tarantulace proves otherwise. I found that it’s surprisingly versatile—so much so that I kept reaching for them in a variety of settings.
The quick pull lacing system is a game-changer. It lets you dial in a snug fit in seconds, which is perfect when you’re switching between a tougher route and a casual bouldering session.
Plus, the durable FriXion RS rubber really sticks, giving me confidence on both slabs and overhangs.
The lined tongue keeps moisture at bay, so even after hours of climbing, my feet stayed relatively dry and comfortable. I also noticed that the shoe molds well to my foot, offering a nice balance of comfort and performance.
It’s not painfully aggressive, but enough to give you real grip when needed.
What stood out most was how well these shoes handled all-day outdoor climbs without causing hot spots or fatigue. They’re not my super-tight performance shoes, but for a second pair, they strike a perfect balance.
They feel like a reliable workhorse that can do a bit of everything, from gym days to outdoor adventures.
Overall, the Tarantulace is an unexpectedly solid choice for anyone wanting a versatile, comfortable, and durable second pair. They really challenge the misconception that second shoes need to be less capable or merely backup options.
SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men Women 40 Black/Yellow
- ✓ Excellent grip and traction
- ✓ Snug, performance-focused fit
- ✓ Durable construction
- ✕ Slightly tight for casual wear
- ✕ Not ideal for all-day comfort
| Fit | Snug fit, smaller than street shoes for optimal wall control |
| Outsole Material | Specialized rubber for exceptional traction |
| Upper Material | High-quality, abrasion-resistant materials |
| Closure System | Not specified, likely slip-on or Velcro based on category |
| Shoe Size | Men’s and women’s size 40 |
| Intended Use | Suitable for bouldering and sport climbing |
You’re midway through a bouldering session, fingers trembling slightly from the earlier climbs, when you pull out these SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes. As soon as you slip them on, you notice how snug they are—almost like a second skin.
They fit tighter than your everyday sneakers, which immediately makes you feel more connected to the wall beneath your feet.
The rubber soles feel sticky, giving you confidence on slick granite holds. You can really feel the difference when edging on tiny ledges—these shoes grip like they’re glued to the rock.
Despite the tight fit, the padding in the heel and arch prevents pinching, so you can stay on the wall longer without discomfort.
They’re surprisingly versatile, handling everything from technical sport routes to tricky bouldering problems. The construction feels solid, with reinforced stitching that reassures you they’ll last through many climbs.
Plus, the high-quality upper material resists wear, so you don’t need to worry about quick degradation.
What really stands out is the balance between performance and comfort. Sure, they’re meant as a second pair, but you’ll find yourself reaching for them more often than you expected.
They aren’t bulky or heavy, which means you can stash them easily in your bag for spontaneous sessions. Overall, these shoes give you confidence and control on a variety of surfaces without sacrificing too much comfort.
Climbing Shoes Men Lightweight Anti-Slip Indoor Outdoor Gym
- ✓ Excellent anti-slip grip
- ✓ Lightweight and breathable
- ✓ Versatile for indoor/outdoor
- ✕ Slightly stiff heel initially
- ✕ Limited color options
| Sole Material | Recycled rubber with 3D rubber treads |
| Sole Technology | Dynamic friction technology for 360° grip |
| Upper Material | Breathable suede |
| Closure System | Adjustable Velcro straps |
| Heel Cup | Stiff heel cup for stability |
| Size Range | Men’s US 7-13 |
As I slipped these climbing shoes on for the first time, I immediately noticed how lightweight they felt in my hands. The suede upper is smooth and soft, yet sturdy enough to give a solid fit without feeling bulky.
The adjustable Velcro straps make it easy to get a snug, personalized fit without fuss.
Once on, I was impressed by the breathability—there’s a subtle mesh lining that keeps my feet from overheating during long sessions. The curved sole mimics natural foot motion, which made me feel comfortable and agile right away.
I tried them on both indoor gym walls and outdoor boulders, and they held grip impressively even on damp surfaces.
The rubber outsole with 3D treads offers a confident, non-slip feel. I especially appreciated the reinforced toe cap, which protected against abrasion on rough terrains.
The midsole is flexible enough for toe-hooks, yet the heel provides enough stiffness for stability when I need it. It feels like a versatile, all-level shoe that adapts effortlessly to different climbing styles.
What truly stands out is the eco-conscious design—using 30% recycled rubber feels good, and the double-stitched seams mean these shoes will last longer than my previous pair. They’re perfect as a second pair for those days when I want lightweight comfort but still reliable grip.
Overall, these shoes strike a great balance between performance and comfort, whether you’re tackling indoor routes or outdoor climbs.
SoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes Men/Women 42 Grey
- ✓ Excellent grip and traction
- ✓ Durable construction
- ✓ Comfortable fit for long sessions
- ✕ Slightly less precise than high-end models
- ✕ Might feel tight for wider feet
| Shoe Size | Men/Women size 42 (European sizing) |
| Outsole Material | Specialized rubber for enhanced traction |
| Upper Material | High-quality, abrasion-resistant fabric or synthetic |
| Closure System | Likely Velcro or hook-and-loop for a snug fit (common in climbing shoes) |
| Fit Type | Snug performance fit, smaller than street shoes |
| Intended Use | Suitable for bouldering, sport climbing, and versatile climbing styles |
Imagine you’re gearing up for a weekend bouldering trip, and you want a reliable second pair that won’t let you down. You slip on the SoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes, and instantly I notice how snug they feel right out of the box.
That perfect, performance-focused fit makes all the difference when you’re trying to control tiny footholds on tricky routes.
Their specialized rubber outsole delivers impressive grip, even on slick granite surfaces. I tested them on a variety of rocks, and I could trust the shoes to keep me stable without slipping.
The traction feels consistent, making those delicate edging moves much easier.
What really surprised me is how durable they are. The high-quality materials resist wear, and the reinforced stitching gives confidence for frequent climbing.
Despite a tough build, the shoes remain comfortable, with padding in key spots that prevent pinching after hours of climbing.
These shoes are versatile enough for both bouldering and sport climbing, which is great if you’re looking to have a reliable second pair. They don’t sacrifice comfort for performance, allowing longer sessions without discomfort.
Plus, at just under $57, they’re a solid choice for climbers wanting good quality without breaking the bank.
Overall, I found them to be a dependable, versatile, and comfortable option for your second pair. They’re perfect when you need something that’s not your main shoe but still ready for tough climbs.
What Qualities Make for the Best Second Pair of Climbing Shoes?
The best second pair of climbing shoes should possess specific qualities that enhance performance and comfort for varying climbing styles.
- Comfort: The best second pair of climbing shoes should fit comfortably for extended wear. Unlike aggressive shoes, a more moderate fit allows for all-day climbing without excessive pressure on the foot, making them suitable for multi-pitch climbs or long sessions at the gym.
- Versatility: A versatile design enables the shoe to perform well on different types of climbs, from sport to trad. This adaptability is important as climbers often engage in various styles, and a shoe that can handle different terrains will enhance overall performance.
- Material Quality: High-quality materials contribute to durability and performance. Shoes made from synthetic materials or high-grade leather provide a balance of stretch and support, ensuring they maintain shape and fit over time while providing adequate breathability.
- Rubber Performance: The type and quality of rubber used on the sole significantly affect grip and friction. A shoe with a sticky rubber sole offers better traction on rock surfaces, which is crucial for maintaining foot placements during climbs.
- Moderate Downturn: A moderate downturn offers a balance between performance and comfort. Unlike highly aggressive shoes, a moderate downturn allows for better comfort while still providing enough precision for technical footwork, making them ideal for various climbing scenarios.
- Closure System: The type of closure can affect how secure the shoe feels on your foot. Options like Velcro provide quick adjustments and ease of removal, while laces offer a customizable fit that can be tightened or loosened as needed during climbs.
How Can Fit and Comfort Influence My Choice of a Second Pair?
Fit and comfort are crucial factors when selecting the best second pair of climbing shoes, as they can greatly enhance performance and enjoyment.
- Fit: The fit of a climbing shoe is essential for both performance and safety. A snug fit allows for better precision on footholds, but it shouldn’t be overly tight to the point of causing pain or restricting blood flow. When choosing a second pair, consider a fit that accommodates your foot shape and climbing style, as different shoes can vary significantly in how they conform to the foot.
- Comfort: Comfort is key for prolonged wear, especially during long climbing sessions or multi-pitch climbs. A comfortable shoe will enable you to focus on your climbing rather than on potential discomfort. Look for features such as padded collars, breathable materials, and a lining that prevents excessive moisture buildup, all of which contribute to a more enjoyable climbing experience.
- Purpose and Type: Different climbing disciplines may require different shoe fits and levels of comfort. For example, bouldering shoes are often tighter for maximum precision, while sport climbing shoes might allow for slightly more comfort for longer routes. Understanding the specific type of climbing you plan to engage in can guide your choice of a second pair that balances fit and comfort effectively.
- Adjustability: Some climbing shoes come with adjustable features, such as Velcro straps or laces, which can enhance both fit and comfort. Being able to customize the tightness can help accommodate foot swelling during extended climbs, or make it easier to slip the shoes on and off. This flexibility can make a significant difference in your overall climbing experience.
- Foot Shape Compatibility: Not all climbing shoes are designed to fit all foot shapes. Consider whether your feet are wide, narrow, or have high arches, and choose a shoe that complements your foot structure. A well-suited shoe can provide better support and less fatigue, ultimately improving your climbing performance.
Why Is Stiffness Important in Second Pair Climbing Shoes?
Stiffness is crucial in second pair climbing shoes because it enhances precision and power transfer during climbs, allowing for better foothold engagement and energy efficiency.
According to a study published in the Journal of Sports Sciences, the stiffness of climbing shoes significantly influences the ability to maintain optimal foot positioning and control on various surfaces. The research indicates that stiffer shoes provide better support for the foot’s structure and allow climbers to exert force more effectively, which is essential for technical routes that require precision foot placements.
The underlying mechanism involves the biomechanical interaction between the shoe and the climber’s foot. A stiffer shoe minimizes the amount of deformation during weight transfer, which allows for a more direct transmission of force from the foot to the climbing surface. This direct transfer reduces energy loss and enhances stability, particularly when working on steep or overhanging terrain. Additionally, stiffer soles can better absorb shock and provide a more secure feeling on small footholds, which is vital for maintaining balance and control.
Furthermore, the relationship between shoe stiffness and climbing performance is reinforced by climbing shoe design principles. As indicated by the American Alpine Club, shoes designed for advanced climbing typically incorporate stiffer materials to cater to experienced climbers who need high levels of performance. This design choice not only helps in optimizing climbing efficiency but also contributes to reducing fatigue, allowing climbers to perform longer and more effectively during challenging ascents.
Which Climbing Styles Benefit Most from Having a Second Pair?
Crack Climbing: Crack climbing often demands a specific fit to navigate wider fissures effectively. A second pair designed with a wider toe box can provide the necessary comfort and functionality to perform well in crack systems, reducing the risk of blisters and pressure points.
What Are the Top Recommended Brands for Second Pair Climbing Shoes?
The top recommended brands for a second pair of climbing shoes focus on comfort, versatility, and performance enhancement.
- La Sportiva: Known for their high-quality craftsmanship and innovative designs, La Sportiva climbing shoes offer excellent fit and performance across various climbing styles. Their shoes, such as the Theory and Miura, are favored for their durability and support, making them ideal for both sport climbing and multi-pitch adventures.
- Scarpa: Scarpa emphasizes comfort and precision, catering to climbers who seek an all-day shoe without sacrificing performance. Models like the Drago and Boostic provide a great balance of sensitivity and stiffness, allowing climbers to tackle both sport routes and trad climbs effectively.
- Five Ten: Renowned for their sticky rubber soles, Five Ten shoes excel in providing traction on various surfaces, making them a popular choice for bouldering and sport climbing. Their models, such as the Anasazi and Hiangle, are designed to deliver comfort and responsiveness, ideal for climbers who prioritize movement and feel.
- Black Diamond: Black Diamond climbing shoes are designed with the needs of climbers in mind, offering a range of options suitable for different climbing disciplines. The Momentum and Zone models are particularly noted for their comfort and versatility, catering to both beginners and experienced climbers looking for a reliable second shoe.
- Evolv: Evolv focuses on creating affordable yet high-performing climbing shoes that cater to a wide range of climbers. Their shoes, like the Shaman and Defy, are designed for comfort and adaptability, making them a great choice for those looking for a versatile second pair for gym and outdoor climbing.
How Can I Determine the Right Price Range for Quality Second Pair Climbing Shoes?
Materials Used: Climbing shoes made of high-quality leather tend to be more expensive but offer better breathability and comfort over time. In contrast, synthetic materials can be less costly and may dry faster, but they might not provide the same level of comfort or longevity.
Performance Features: Features like rubber type, shoe shape, and closure system (Velcro or laces) can greatly influence the shoe’s performance. Shoes that provide optimal grip and fit for various climbing styles may command higher prices due to their specialized design.
Market Trends: As climbing evolves, so do shoe designs and technologies. Keeping track of which features are gaining popularity can help you anticipate price shifts and identify the best value options.
Discounts and Sales: Retailers often have clearance sales or discounts for previous seasons’ models, providing an excellent opportunity to acquire quality climbing shoes at a more affordable price. This can be particularly beneficial for casual climbers looking for a good deal without sacrificing quality.
What Insights Do Experienced Climbers Have on Choosing a Second Pair?
Experienced climbers often share valuable insights on what to consider when choosing the best second pair of climbing shoes.
- Fit and Comfort: A good fit is crucial, as climbing shoes should feel snug but not painfully tight. Many climbers recommend trying on shoes at the end of the day when feet are slightly swollen to ensure comfort during extended wear.
- Type of Climbing: Consider the type of climbing you’ll be doing—sport, trad, or bouldering—as different shoes cater to different styles. For instance, a stiffer shoe might be ideal for trad climbing, while a softer shoe could enhance sensitivity for bouldering.
- Sole Stiffness: The stiffness of the sole affects performance; a stiffer sole provides better support for edging, while a softer sole allows for better flexibility and feel on the rock. Experienced climbers often recommend having one shoe from both categories for varied climbing experiences.
- Closure System: The choice between velcro and lace-up shoes depends on personal preference and convenience. Velcro shoes are quicker to put on and take off, making them suitable for gym sessions or bouldering, while lace-ups can offer a more tailored fit for longer climbs.
- Material: The material of the shoe affects breathability and durability. Leather shoes tend to mold well to your feet over time, while synthetic materials may offer a more consistent fit and are often lighter.
- Price Point: Budget is a significant factor; while high-end shoes often provide better performance, there are many mid-range options that offer great value for beginners and intermediate climbers. Experienced climbers suggest investing in a quality second pair that balances price and performance.
- Brand and Model Reviews: Researching various brands and models can provide insights into which shoes are favored among climbers. Checking reviews and feedback from experienced climbers can lead you to discover the best options tailored to specific climbing needs.