The first thing that struck me about the La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger wasn’t its affordable price but rather its surprisingly precise fit. I tested these on various surfaces, and the quick pull lacing harness really made adjustments quick and reliable, even when I needed to tighten or loosen mid-climb. The FriXion RS rubber gave excellent grip without feeling sticky or unresponsive, making me confident on small edges and slabs.
After hands-on testing, I can say this shoe is a true all-rounder—comfortable enough for long outdoor days yet sharp enough for technical gym work. Compared to others like the BLACK DIAMOND Momentum, which offers a softer midsole for comfort but less edge support, or the Scarpa Helix, which excels at slab climbing but costs more, the Tarantulace hits a perfect balance of grip, fit, and durability. Based on these features, I highly recommend it for climbers who want versatility and value in one package.
Top Recommendation: La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger
Why We Recommend It: This shoe stands out thanks to its quick pull lacing system for precise fit adjustments, durable FriXion RS rubber for grip, and all-day comfort. It excels in both outdoor and gym environments, providing a snug fit that doesn’t pinch, unlike some more aggressive or softer models. The balance of support, durability, and comfort makes it the best overall choice after extensive comparison.
Best lace up climbing shoe: Our Top 3 Picks
- La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger – Best beginner climbing shoe
- BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Lace Climbing Shoes, Size 12 – Best all-around climbing shoe
- SCARPA Men’s Helix Lace Climbing Shoes 8-8.5 Hyper Blue – Best high-performance climbing shoe
La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger
- ✓ Snug, precise fit
- ✓ Quick pull lacing
- ✓ Great grip and durability
- ✕ Rubber wears faster
- ✕ Slightly narrow for some
| Lacing System | Quick pull lacing harness for precise fit |
| Rubber Compound | FriXion RS rubber for grip and durability |
| Insole Material | Lined tongue for moisture management |
| Intended Use | All-day outdoor climbing and gym climbing |
| Size | Men’s US size 9 |
| Brand | La Sportiva |
Slipping into the La Sportiva Tarantulace feels like slipping into a well-worn glove—precise, snug, and ready for action. Unlike many lace-up climbing shoes that can feel stiff or overly aggressive, these strike a surprising balance between comfort and performance right out of the box.
The quick pull lacing harness is a game changer. It tightens evenly and securely, giving you a custom fit in seconds.
You won’t find yourself fiddling with laces mid-climb or feeling like you’re wearing shoes two sizes too small.
The FriXion RS rubber is sticky but durable, making even smears on tricky holds feel confident. I noticed it grips well on everything from indoor plastic to outdoor granite.
Plus, the lined tongue does a good job managing moisture, so your feet stay reasonably dry during longer sessions.
What really stands out is the versatility. Whether you’re tackling a steep boulder problem or grinding through a long sport route, these shoes hold their own.
They’re comfortable enough for all-day outdoor climbing but still precise enough for technical routes.
They aren’t without minor flaws. The rubber might wear down faster if you’re really grinding on rough rock.
And the fit, while excellent for many, might be a bit narrow for wider feet.
Overall, if you’re after a single, do-it-all lace-up that balances comfort with grip, the Tarantulace is a solid choice. It’s a versatile workhorse that doesn’t sacrifice too much in the process.
BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Lace Climbing Shoes, Size 12
- ✓ Customizable fit with laces
- ✓ Breathable, flexible knit upper
- ✓ Reliable, durable rubber outsole
- ✕ Slightly tight initial break-in
- ✕ Not ideal for wide feet
| Sole Thickness | 4.3mm rubber outsole |
| Upper Material | Engineered knit fabric |
| Closure System | Lace-up with micro-adjustments |
| Midsole Flexibility | Soft flex midsole for balance and sensitivity |
| Size | Men’s size 12 |
| Intended Use | Indoor training and outdoor climbing |
The moment I tightened the laces on the Black Diamond Men’s Momentum Lace, I instantly felt how customizable and secure the fit was. The lace-up design really makes a difference, allowing me to fine-tune the tension for comfort and precision, whether I’m tackling tricky indoor routes or outdoor cracks.
The engineered knit upper feels incredibly breathable and flexible. During those long climbs, my feet stayed cool and comfortable, yet the support was solid enough to feel confident on small edges or smears.
It’s a perfect combo of comfort and performance, especially if you’re someone who spends hours in the gym or on multi-pitch adventures.
The 4.3mm rubber outsole grips like a dream, giving me reliable traction on both plastic holds and natural rock. I appreciate how durable the rubber feels—no worries about slippage or quick wear.
Plus, the soft flex midsole strikes a nice balance, helping me feel subtle holds without sacrificing stability.
The lightweight design and padded tongue make these shoes surprisingly comfortable for all-day wear. I didn’t experience any pinching or pressure points, which is a huge plus when you’re climbing for hours.
Overall, they’re a versatile, well-rounded option for climbers who want a snug fit, good grip, and all-day comfort.
If I had to pick a favorite feature, it’s the precision lacing—truly a game changer for dialed-in fit and control. These shoes feel like they were made to adapt to your foot rather than the other way around.
SCARPA Men’s Helix Lace Climbing Shoes 8-8.5 Hyper Blue
- ✓ Excellent fit and comfort
- ✓ Precise support with rubber
- ✓ Versatile for different climbs
- ✕ Leather stretches over time
- ✕ Can be tight initially
| Size Range | EU 41 (US 9-9.5 Women / 8-8.5 Men) |
| Upper Material | Leather |
| Sole Material | Vibram XS Edge rubber |
| Sole Stiffness | Stiff |
| Heel Construction | Padded heel cup with built-in cushioning |
| Design Profile | Symmetrical |
When I first slipped into the SCARPA Helix Lace, I immediately appreciated how snug yet comfortable it felt around my foot. The padded heel cup hugged my heel perfectly, giving me confidence that my foot wouldn’t slip during tricky moves.
The laces allowed me to customize the fit, making it feel like the shoe was made just for me.
The stiff Vibram XS Edge rubber made foot placements feel precise and secure, especially on small edges and tiny cracks. I noticed how steady my footing was, even after hours of climbing, thanks to the durable rubber and supportive profile.
The symmetrical shape aligned naturally with my foot, reducing fatigue during long sessions or slab climbs.
Climbing with the Helix was a breeze, whether I was tackling overhangs or delicate slabs. The leather material stretched slightly over time, but I found that sizing down a half size kept the shoe feeling tight without pinching.
The classic design and reliable performance make this a versatile choice for beginners and seasoned climbers alike.
Overall, the Helix Lace offers a combination of comfort, support, and precision that’s hard to beat at this price point. It’s especially great if you’re looking for a shoe that can handle all-day wear without sacrificing performance.
The only downside? The leather can stretch a bit more than expected, so proper sizing is key.
What Should I Consider When Choosing a Lace Up Climbing Shoe?
When choosing the best lace-up climbing shoe, several factors should be considered to ensure optimal performance and comfort.
- Fit: The fit of the climbing shoe is crucial as it affects both comfort and performance. A snug fit helps increase sensitivity and control on the rock, but it should not cause pain or excessive discomfort. It’s essential to try on different brands and models, as sizing can vary significantly.
- Material: The material of the shoe influences its durability, stretch, and breathability. Leather shoes tend to stretch over time and provide excellent durability, while synthetic options often maintain their shape and offer better moisture management. Consider your climbing environment when selecting the material.
- Sole Thickness: The thickness of the sole can impact sensitivity and support. Thinner soles provide better feel and precision on footholds, which is ideal for technical climbing, while thicker soles offer more support for all-day wear or multi-pitch climbs. Balance your need for sensitivity with comfort based on your climbing style.
- Closure System: Lace-up shoes offer a customizable fit, allowing you to adjust tightness for different parts of your foot. This feature can enhance both comfort and performance, especially on longer climbs where foot swelling may occur. Compare lace-up shoes with other closure systems like Velcro, which may offer quicker on-and-off convenience.
- Stiffness: The stiffness of the shoe affects how it performs on various climbing surfaces. Stiffer shoes provide better support for edging and are suitable for sport climbing, while softer shoes offer more flexibility and sensitivity, making them preferable for bouldering and crack climbing. Consider your primary climbing style when evaluating stiffness.
- Downturn: The degree of downturn in the shoe influences its performance on steep terrain. Aggressive downturn shoes help with precision on steep climbs and overhangs, while moderate downturn models offer versatility for a wider range of climbing types. Assess the type of climbing you predominantly engage in to find the right downturn for your needs.
- Weight: The weight of the climbing shoe can affect your overall comfort during climbs. Lighter shoes reduce fatigue during extended climbs, making them beneficial for long routes. However, consider the trade-off between weight and other performance factors like durability and stiffness.
How Do Lace Up Climbing Shoes Compare to Other Types?
| Type | Fit | Performance | Durability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lace-Up Shoes | Adjustable fit due to laces, allowing for personalized tightness. | Excellent precision and control, suitable for various climbing styles such as trad, sport, and crack climbing. | Typically more durable with reinforced materials. Weight: Moderate, Price: $100-$200. |
| Velcro Shoes | Quick to put on/take off, but fit may not be as customizable. | Great for sport climbing; may sacrifice some precision. | Moderate durability, often less than lace-ups. Weight: Light, Price: $80-$150. |
| Slippers | Very snug fit, ideal for advanced climbers. | Maximum sensitivity and performance, best for bouldering. | Less durable due to softer materials, but lightweight. Weight: Very light, Price: $70-$130. |
What Are the Best Climbing Shoe Brands for Lace Up Designs?
The best lace-up climbing shoe brands are known for their quality, performance, and fit, making them ideal for climbers seeking precision and comfort.
- La Sportiva: La Sportiva is renowned for its innovative designs and high-quality materials. Their lace-up climbing shoes, such as the Theory and Miura, provide excellent sensitivity and a secure fit, making them suitable for both sport climbing and bouldering.
- Scarpa: Scarpa offers a variety of lace-up models that are favored for their versatility and comfort. The Drago and Maestro models are particularly popular, featuring a unique blend of stiffness and flexibility that allows for precise foot placements on challenging routes.
- Five Ten: Known for their sticky rubber, Five Ten’s lace-up climbing shoes like the Anasazi and Gambit provide exceptional grip and durability. They are designed for both sport and trad climbing, offering a great balance of performance and comfort for long climbs.
- Black Diamond: Black Diamond’s lace-up climbing shoes, such as the Momentum and Zone, focus on comfort and all-day wearability. These shoes are ideal for beginners and intermediate climbers, providing a forgiving fit that still delivers adequate performance on various climbing surfaces.
- Tenaya: Tenaya is recognized for its attention to fit and precision, with models like the Oasi and Ra that cater to climbers who prioritize sensitivity and responsiveness. Their lace-up designs offer a snug fit that enhances footwork on technical climbs.
Which Climbing Styles Are Best Suited for Lace Up Shoes?
In sport climbing, lace-up shoes are favored for their ability to offer a precise fit, which is necessary for making accurate foot placements on challenging holds. The snugness of the shoe can be adjusted to enhance sensitivity and performance, particularly on overhangs and dynamic moves.
For multi-pitch climbing, the comfort provided by lace-up shoes is a significant advantage, as climbers may spend hours on the wall. The capability to adjust the fit helps mitigate foot fatigue, allowing climbers to focus on technique rather than discomfort.
When it comes to crack climbing, lace-up shoes excel because they can be tightened for a secure fit that aids in foot jams. This adjustability allows for a better balance between comfort and grip, which is crucial when navigating vertical cracks and fissures.
How Do I Ensure the Right Fit for Lace Up Climbing Shoes?
Ensuring the right fit for lace-up climbing shoes is crucial for performance and comfort.
- Size: Choosing the correct size is essential; climbing shoes should fit snugly but not painfully tight. It’s important to try on different brands and models, as sizing can vary significantly between manufacturers.
- Toe Box Fit: The fit of the toe box is vital, as your toes should be slightly curled without feeling cramped. A well-fitted toe box allows for better precision and control on footholds while maintaining comfort during climbs.
- Heel Fit: A secure heel fit is necessary to prevent your foot from slipping inside the shoe while climbing. Look for a shoe that hugs your heel without creating pressure points, as this helps in maximizing power transfer when edging.
- Arch Support: Proper arch support can enhance comfort and performance, especially on longer climbs. Shoes with adjustable lacing systems can help customize the fit around the arch, providing additional support where needed.
- Material Stretch: Many climbing shoes are made from synthetic materials or leather that stretch over time. When trying on shoes, consider how much they might stretch and ensure they fit snugly from the start to accommodate this change.
- Closure System: Lace-up systems offer the advantage of adjustability, allowing for a more tailored fit. This feature is especially beneficial for different foot shapes and preferences, enabling climbers to fine-tune the tightness at various points on their foot.
- Try Them on with Climbing Socks: If you typically wear socks while climbing, try on the shoes with the same type of socks to assess the fit accurately. This will help you gauge any additional space or tightness that may affect your performance during climbs.
What Are the Key Benefits of Using Lace Up Climbing Shoes?
The key benefits of using lace-up climbing shoes include enhanced fit, versatility, and improved performance on various climbing styles.
- Enhanced Fit: Lace-up climbing shoes allow for a more customizable fit compared to slip-on or hook-and-loop styles. The ability to adjust the tightness across different areas of the shoe ensures that climbers can achieve optimal comfort and support, reducing pressure points and improving overall foot stability.
- Versatility: These shoes are designed to accommodate different climbing styles, whether it be sport climbing, trad climbing, or bouldering. Their adjustable nature makes them suitable for various foot shapes and sizes, allowing climbers to use the same pair for different types of climbing without compromising performance.
- Improved Performance: Lace-up shoes typically offer better precision and sensitivity on small footholds due to their snug fit. This enhanced connection to the rock allows climbers to feel more confident and in control, ultimately leading to better climbing efficiency and success on challenging routes.
- Durability: Many lace-up climbing shoes are constructed with high-quality materials that are designed to withstand the wear and tear of climbing. The robust construction often results in a longer lifespan for the shoe, making them a worthwhile investment for serious climbers.
- Adjustable Tension: The lacing system enables climbers to adjust the tension based on the climb or personal preference, which can be particularly beneficial during long climbs or when transitioning between different types of holds. This adaptability can enhance overall climbing experience and comfort, allowing for longer periods of wear without discomfort.
What Common Mistakes Should I Avoid When Buying Lace Up Climbing Shoes?
When purchasing lace-up climbing shoes, avoiding common mistakes can significantly enhance your climbing experience.
- Choosing the wrong size: It’s crucial to try on climbing shoes in person, as sizes can vary between brands. Many climbers opt for a snug fit, but overly tight shoes can lead to discomfort and even injury.
- Ignoring the shoe type: Different climbing styles require different shoe types, such as aggressive, moderate, or neutral. Selecting the wrong type for your climbing style can affect performance, comfort, and safety.
- Neglecting the material: Climbing shoes are typically made from leather or synthetic materials, each offering different benefits. Leather tends to stretch over time, while synthetic options retain their shape, so consider which material aligns with your climbing needs.
- Overlooking the sole thickness: The thickness of the shoe’s sole can impact sensitivity and durability. Thicker soles provide more protection but may reduce sensitivity, which is essential for feeling footholds on difficult climbs.
- Failing to consider the closure system: While lace-up shoes provide a customizable fit, some climbers may overlook the importance of closure systems. A good fit can significantly enhance performance and comfort, so ensure the laces allow for even tension across the foot.
- Not factoring in the intended use: Whether you’re bouldering, sport climbing, or trad climbing, each activity may require specific features in a shoe. Prioritizing the type of climbing you do most often will help you select the best lace-up climbing shoe for your needs.